Can Jewel Changi Airport continue to shine, for both Singaporeans and foreign travellers?

https://www.todayonline.com/commentary/can-jewel-changi-airport-continue-shine-both-singaporeans-and-foreign-travellers

(Courtesy of TODAY)

Advertisements

Skytrax Best Airports 2019: No surprises

Generally the Skytrax list of top ten airports does not surprise. It’s very much the same again this year, with the airlines staying in the same rank or switching positions one up or down. Frankfurt Airport is the ony one to drop out of the list, replaced by Tokyo Narita.

Courtesy Changi Airport

Singapore Changi wins hands down, a record seven years. With continuing construction of new facilities and upgrading works, it is one hard to beat. Changi pampers the travellers, and respondents give it top honours for leisure amenities. But it is ranked behind Seoul Incheon and the Japanese airports of Tokyo Narita, Tokyo Haneda and Centrair Nagoya for airport staff service. It is also second to Seoul Incheon for international transit.

Worthy of note is again the absence of North American airports but the rising popularity of Japanese airports. No surprise that Tokyo Haneda and Centrair Nagoya are the two cleanest, with Tokyo Narita and Kansai also in the list. Doha Hamad International is the only Middle East airport in the top ten, and you may ask where is Dubai International as the world’s busiest airport. The list is generally dominated by Asian airports, but European airports have managed to maintain some presence in the top ranks: Munich (7th), London Heathrow (8th) and Zurich (10th).

The modern airport is today more than a mere transportation centre facilitating movement from one place to another, but a metropolis in its own right as airports compete to keep the numbers coming. Shopping for example is an important feature, for which London Heathrow wins the day. So too is dining, for which Hong Kong is a consistent winner.

The form impresses, but it is empty if not supported by substance. The basics are still important, such as baggage delivery which according to the survey is best provided by Kansai.

A new category introduced this year – best website and digital services – sees the mention of an American winner: entity: Houston Airports System. By he way, Houston George Bush is ranked fifth for dining. So there is hope, America!

Same airports in Skytrax’s best ten 2018

The 2018 Skytrax list of world’s top 10 airports is a gentle rejuggling of last year’s list which may be divided into three parts. The top three airports remain the same as the next three, and so too the last three with Chubu Central in the same 7th position.

Courtesy Changi Airport Group

Singapore Changi tops the list for six consecutive years, a remarkable feat that according to Skytrax “is the first time in the history of the awards that an airport has won this prestige.” Its closest rival is Seoul’s Incheon International in second place, followed by Tokyo Haneda, which has been making impressive stride in recent years. In fact, Haneda was 2nd last year, and Incheon third.

The other airports in the top ten list are Hong Kong International (4th ), Hamad International (5th), Munich (6th), London Heathrow (8th), Zurich (9th) and Frankfurt (10th).

Changi scored with the best amenities, enhanced by the addition of a new terminal (T4) and the upgrading of Terminal 1. With continual upgrading works and the opening of the aptly named Jewel Changi Airport facility next year – a complex of gardens and more leisure activities – it looks like it may yet again achieve the top honour.

However, Changi is second to Hong Kong for transit and dining, and second to London Heathrow for shopping. It ranks behind Taiwan Taoyuan (1st), Incheon (2nd) and Tokyo Haneda (3rd) for customer service, and much lower in 7th position for baggage delivery. Incheon and Japanese airports score high in these areas. Not surprisingly, Japanese airports score top marks for cleanliness.

Don’t bet on the list changing much next year. Airports are massive investments that take time to materialise, and many of the existing ones are quite content to be functional and hopefully efficient than to be wowing! Yet note that Beijing Captial, which was one of the ten best from 2012 to 2015 has dropped to 34th position.

As appeared to be the order of the day, there is a noticeable absence of US airports with the first mention in Denver airport, ranked 29th. Canadian airports fared a little better, with Vancouver International which was among the ten best for three consecutive years 2012-2014 now ranked 14th but still the best in North America, and Toronto Pearson ranked 41st.

What do Conde Nast best airports have in common?

Yet again – and again – no surprise who tops Conde Nast’s pick of the best airport, or even the top five which are located either in Asia or the Middle East What do these airports have in common?

According to Conde Nast, they stand out “with enough amenities and time-wasters that you might be a little late boarding that flight.” Such frills include indoor waterfalls and great restaurants. In other words, they have to be more than just a fucntional facility for air transportation – however efficient although one must assume efficiency is a key consideration.

Courtesy Changi Airport Group

Top in the ranks is Singapore Changi, followed by Seoul’s Incheon, Dubai International, Hong Kong International and Doha’s Hamad International.

Size matters. They are all huge airports. Changi has a handling capacity of 82 million passengers a year. Incheon is adding a second terminal which will double capacity to 100 million passengers annually, and Dubai Intl is aiming for 200 million passengers yearly. Hong Kong Intl handled more than 70 million passengers last year. Opened only in 2014, Hamad Intl is fast growing, recording a throughput of 37 million passengers last year, an increase of 20%.

They are hub airports. Dubai is now the world’s largest airport for international passenger throughput, edging out London Heathrow. Hong Kong Intl is positioning itself as a gateway to Asia in competition with Changi, with connections to some 50 destinations in China.

They are supported by strong home airlines with extensive connections: Qatar Airways (Hamad Intl), Cathay Pacific (Hong Kong Intl), Emirates Airlines (Dubai Intl), Korean Air and Asiana Airlines (Incheon) and Singapore Airlines (Changi).

They are modern with state-of-the-art infrastructure, and are constantly upgrading. Changi has recently added a fourth terminal where passengers can expect hassle-free processes from check-in to boarding without the need of any human contact.

The Asian airports offer fast rail connections to the city.

And, they are all competing to provide the most alluring “time-wasters”. Changi made news when it offered a swimming pool where passengers with time on their hand could relax and soak int he tropical sun. Now that’s also available at Hamad Intl, where you may even play a game of squash too. While Dubai is known to be one of the world’s biggest duty-free shopping centres, Hong Kong Intl is reputed for its great restaurants. Incheon is uniquely Korean with its “Cultural Street” that showcases local cuisine, dance performances, and arts and craft workshops. It also boasts an indoor skating rink and a spa. Hamad Intl too has an exhibit hall for that cultural touch.

Changi comes closest to being a destination in itself where it is said a passenger wouldn’t mind a flight delay. Besides the swimming pool, there are: an indoor waterfall, a butterfly garden, a swimming pool, vast play areas for families with children, and an array of restaurants and shops. And for passengers with at least a transit of six hours, you can hope on a free city tour.

But, of course, all these would not mean much if they are not supported by efficiency and friendly service.

Asian airports dominate Skytrax best rankings

Courtesy Changi Airport Group

Not surprising that Singapore Changi clinched Skytrax’s 2017 Best Airport award for the fifth year running, commended for having the best leisure activities. As a hub airport, it is how best travellers are relieved of the stress of travel that will garner an airport favourable ratings. Changi is a favourite transit airport with its array of amenities, restaurants and shops.

What else can we infer from the survey said to be based on 13.82 million responses from 105 different nationalities, conducted from July 2016 to Feb 2017?

The top spots are held by familiar names of the last five to six years – Incheon International (3rd), Munich (4th), Hong Kong International (5th), Munich (4th), Zurich (8th) and London Heathrow (9th).

Incheon was ranked the best airport in 2012 before Changi took over in 2013, and until this year, it was a close second.

Special mention should be made of London Heathrow, which was the world’s busiest airport for international traffic until Dubai took the honours from it for two years now – Dubai did not make it to the list as being among the best.

It would appear that performance consistency is key, yet stagnation can lead to one losing the competitive edge. Changi has always prided itself as being innovative, constantly upgrading and expanding its facilities.

Making strides are Tokyo Haneda (2nd) and Doha’s Hamad International (6th). Tokyo Haneda was ranked 9th in 2013, 5th in 2015, 4th last year and 2nd this year. Hamad entered the top ten list at the bottom last year and made it up to 6th this year.

Besides Tokyo Haneda, there is a second Japanese airport in the list, namely Centrair Nagoya (7th). Tokyo Narita and Kansai Osaka were also ranked in previous years. It does say a lot about Japanese airport management.

It is no surprise that four Japanese airports are ranked among the top ten cleanest airports – Tokyo Haneda (1st), Centrair Nagoya (3rd), Tokyo Narita (5th) and Kansai Osaka (9th). Except for Zurich (8th) and Hamad (10th), this list is dominated by Asian airports, the others being Incheon (2nd), Taiwan’s Taoyuan (4th), Changi (6th) and Hong Kong (7th).

Similarly, the best airport staff service list is made up of nine Asian airports with the exeption of Vienna (10th): Taoyuan (1st), Incheon (2nd), Tokyo Haneda (3rd), Changi (4th), Centrair Nagoya (5th), Kansai Osaka (6th), Kuala Lupur International (7th), Tokyo Narita (8th) and Hong Kong (9th). Clearly service is an Asian strength.

One other Asian airport deserves some mention as the most improved airport – Jakarta’s Soekarno-Hatta Airport. Will it make it to the list as one of the world’s best?

By bow you have noticed that no airport outside Asia, the Middle East and Europe are listed in this year’s Skytrax top ten/ The only outsider was Vancouver International which was ranked 9th in 2012, 8th in 2013 and 9th in 2014. Yet again, this does not come as a surprise.

Singapore Changi is world’s best airport according to Conde Nast

Courtesy Alamy

Courtesy Alamy

IT is no surprise that Singapore Changi is voted yet again the world’s best airport by readers of Conde Nast. The airport has long been a darling of transit travellers, particularly those who needed a refreshing break for recharge on a long haul or those who wanted to waste no time in connecting to their final destination

If you consider Conde Nast readers’ choice of the top ten airports, Changi gets top marks for its facilities and amenities which contribute to its ideal of being a destination in itself, complete with indoor gardens and a waterfall, open-air decks and variety of restaurants, numerous shops, various lounges for all classes of travellers, a swimming pool and even a free 24-hour cinema. There are also quite nap areas to catch forty winks.

Little wonder that Qatar’s Hamad International (ranked 3rd), Dubai International (5th) and Hong Kong International (6th) are also noted for their shops and lounges. Hamad International has a hotel inside the terminal, which is a boon for travellers with long layovers needing to rest for half or a full day. Dubai International is the world’s third busiest airport but number one in terms of international travellers, and is long known to have the world’s biggest duty-free shop.

A wide network and quick connections are significant features of these airports. Hong Kong International, for example, is a popular regional hub with connections to some 50 destinations in China. This airport is often ranked as one of the top three airports in the region along with Changi and Seoul International, which took second place in the Conde Nast survey.

Proximity to the city and quick access seem to also swing the decision of Conde Nast readers in the airport’s favour.  Tokyo Haneda (8th) is only a 13-minute ride via rail to the city, compared to Narita. It s popularity has increased with more direct services offered by both Japanese and American carriers between Japan and the US. Denmark’s Copenhagen Airport is also a short ride of 12 minutes via train from the airport. And if you are travelling to or from Canada’s Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (4th), it is an even shorter 6-minute walk via a pedestrian tunnel.

Other airports ranked in the top ten by Conde Nast are Helsinki Airport (9th) and Zurich Airport (10th).

Changi boosts capacity to combat competition

Courtesy CAG

Courtesy CAG

Singapore Changi Airport does not hide its ambition to be the region’s hub airport, and it is not sparing any effort including spending lots in holding on to that dream. Works are in progress for a fourth terminal, costing S$1.3 billion (US$949 million), to be completed by the last quarter of 2017, and this will be followed by the construction of a fifth terminal to be fully operational by 2025.

As competition among regional airports intensifies – the region being redefined in this age of long range aircraft to include Middle East airports such as Dubai International – it looks like creating capacity within impressive architectural structures complete with the ultimate in creature comfort and distractions (or attractions, so to speak) is the answer to staying ahead of the competition. That has been evidenced to a degree by Changi consistently winning awards as one of the world’s best airports.

Indeed, no airport is more passionately engaged in continually expanding and upgrading its facilities than Changi. Terminal 4 will add another 16 million passengers per year to existing capacity at three terminals of 66 million passengers. With the planned capacity of Terminal 5 to handle up to 50 million passengers, this will give Changi a total capacity of 132 million passengers by 2020. Terminal 5, according to Changi Airport Group (CAG), is set to be one of the largest terminals in the world if not third after Dubai and Beijing. And it looks like the project does not end there in land scarce Singapore. CAG said in its statement: “There will be land for subsequent expansion.”

There’s a lot of conviction there, and optimism no less. Last year Changi handled 55.4 million passengers, which means the airport was operating under capacity of close to 20 per cent. But that is not an issue of concern; viewed positively, Changi is well equipped to assimilate any unprecedented growth surge without bursting at its seams. The numbers for December looked good, and it is an optimistic 2016 ahead. Not having enough capacity to net the growth would be the greater evil. Besides, planning ahead, the extra room is to be expected. Then again there is the argument that capacity creates growth, and considering the lead time in airport development, Changi will not be caught short on supply. Of no lesser influence are the plans of competing airports such as Dubai to increase its capacity from 80 million to 250 million passengers, and Korea’s Incheon Airport similarly from 80 million to 145 million passengers.

The real issue, however, is whether the excess capacity is realistic vis-à-vis without creating uneconomical white elephant space. Historical data show Changi growing at an average rate of 2.85 per cent from 2011 to 2015.
Of course, convenient straight line extrapolation can be off the mark when the near term is expected to perform above average. Going forward, Changi’s growth is likely to be higher as demand for seats rises on the back of an improved global economy. According to the International Air Transport Association (IATA), air travel will continue to accelerate and expand by an average of 5.3 per cent this year, which is higher than Changi’s best year in recent times. Asia-Pacific along with Latin America and the Middle East will see the strongest passenger growth, with China leading the field, growing above the global average. Changi will need to target an annual growth rate of about nine per cent over the next two years to maintain its current level of overcapacity by the time Terminal 4 is operational. Whether that is a reasonable buffer is a different issue and dependent upon how CAG visualises the competition, but consider how Terminal 5 will add another 50 million passengers less than a decade down the road.

By comparison, close rival Hong Kong International Airport (HKIA) grew 8.1 per cent last year to reach 68.5 million passengers, which is 23.6 per cent higher than Changi’s number. HKIA is expected to continue to grow at the same rate, particularly with the rising demand for air travel in China, which, according to IATA, will account for 193 million (of which 34 million will be travelling internationally) or nearly a quarter of the 831 million new passengers in its forecast. Situated at the doorstep of mainland China, HKIA has the edge over Changi, which will also benefit from the Chinese yen to travel abroad with Singapore as an attractive destination and a convenient stopover hop to other destinations. What has become more challenging for Changi is HKIA’s increased positioning as the gateway to Asia for trans-Pacific traffic.

The Asia-Pacific region itself is expected to add some 380 million passengers both domestically and internationally. Changi, which has experienced double-digit growth in budget traffic in recent years that outperformed full-service airlines, will benefit from regional traffic particularly with the long overdue full implementation of the Asean Open Skies. Connections with secondary airports will boost the number through Changi, whose top ten city links by passenger traffic in 2015 were all within Asia with the exception of Sydney at the bottom of the list (unless as some Australian politicians would have preferred it to be considered more appropriately aligned to the Asian economic bloc). Jakarta, Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur, Hong Kong and Manila are ranked the top five in that order.

However, as a hub airport which is highly dependent on connecting traffic, Changi is challenged by increased non-stop flights between destinations for the long haul and by alternative hubs, its most notable loss being the shift in 2013 by Qantas for its Kangaroo Route flights to stop at Dubai instead of Changi. Dubai has gained significant hub status for connections to not only Gulf destinations but also airports in Europe, Africa and the Americas. Changi’s competition used to be limited to nearby airports such as Bangkok Suvarnabhumi (since Don Muang) and Kuala Lumpur International (since Subang), not even including then Hong Kong Kai Tak (before its successor at chap lap Kok), the competition has widened to as far away as Dubai, which has emerged as Changi’s biggest threat. The Middle East airport, which is home to Emirates Airlines, boasted to have surpassed London Heathrow when it reported 11-month passenger traffic of 70.96 million passengers last year. That feat embraced an earlier victory in surpassing Changi. Notably, both HKIA and Dubai are handling more passengers than Changi.

To meet the challenges, Changi announced it has launched several initiatives to boost air traffic management capabilities and capacity. Indeed, as Singapore Senior Minister of State for Transport said, “It is not going to be enough just to build airport capacity and have lots of room for airlines to move in and out, because if you don’t have the air traffic management capabilities, you won’t be able to deal with the capacity.”As an example, Changi reduces the separation between airlines to allow more flights to land and take off. By the end of the next decade, Changi could handle 700, 000 flights a year, twice as many as it is handling presently.

CAG chief executive Lee Seow Hiang said: “2015 was a year of two halves for Changi Airport. Following 2014, which saw a number of airline incidents in the region and depressed yields for many regional carriers, we had a relatively weak first six months with flat growth for the period. Nevertheless, we pressed on to actively woo new airlines and seek growth opportunities with existing ones, and our efforts have yielded some positive outcomes.”

Last year Changi welcomed eight new carriers which are largely regional and no-frill operators, including Batik Air, Thai Lion Air and Myanmar National Airlines. Ten new points including Lucknow in India and Luang Prabang in Laos were also added to its network. More links including Nadi by Fiji Airways and Dusseldorf by Singapore Airlines are in the offing.

Mr Lee added: “Changi Airport is well placed to capture future growth with our expanding network, including many secondary cities, to key markets like China, India and Indonesia. We will continue to work closely with our airline partners to establish new connections to develop the Singapore air hub and better serve our passengers.”

So much for the optimism and with the industry blessed with favourable economic factors such as the low fuel price and the region’s growing affluence and its untapped tourism potential, this year and the next leading to the opening of the new Terminal 4 certainly look like exciting times of expectations for Changi. With so much money sunk into the projects, naturally there will be concerns about costs among users. Budget carrier Jetstar Asia CEO Barathan Pasupathi said: In 2016, even though fuel prices have come off in the market, our paramount challenge in Singapore is cost relative to Southeast Asia. For Singapore which is putting so much of investment in capital expenditure and in investments into airports – with Terminal 4, Terminal 5 (and) Runway 3, it’s going to be very important to find a model where Singapore is cost competitive as a hub.”

However you view Changi’s ambition, the airport will be an aviation jewel of showcase reputation. Not difficult to figure out if that in itself is a significant driver in the race to be the world’s best.